1665-1675 REV. THOMAS GOULD
1679-1680 REV. JOHN RUSSELL, JR
1681-1689, 1694-1699 REV. ISAAC HULL
1684-1699 REV. JOHN EMBLEM
1708-1726 REV. ELLIS CALLENDER
1718-1738 REV. ELISHA CALLENDER
1738-1764 REV. JEREMIAH CONDY
1764-1807 REV. DR. SAMUEL STILLMAN
1807-1809 REV. JOSEPH CLAY
1814-1820 REV. JAMES M WINCHELL
1821-1826 REV. DR. FRANCIS WAYLAND, JR
1827-1830 REV. CYRUS PITT GROVENSOR
1831-1837 REV. WILLIAM HAGUE
1837-1877 REV. DR. ROLLIN HEBER NEALE
1878-1884 REV. DR. CEPHAS BENNETT CRANE
1885-1893 REV. DR. PHILIP STAFFORD MOXON
1894-1899 REV. DR. NATHAN EUSEBIUS WOOD
1900-1910 REV. DR. FRANCIS HAROLD ROWLEY
1911-1925 REV. DR. AUSTEN KENNEDY DeBLOIS
1926-1936 REV. DR. HAROLD MAJOR
1936-1940 REV. DR. HERBERT S. JOHNSON
1940-1947 REV. HARRY H. KRUENER
1947-1956 REV. JOHN U. MILLER
1958-1961 REV. EDWARD L. GUNTHER
1961-1970 REV. CHARLES W. GRIFFIN
1971-1981 REV. J. WALTER SILLEN
1982-2001 REV. DR. MILTON P. RYDER
2003-2006 REV. JAY WARREN VanHORN
2008-2014 REV. DR. STEPHEN BUTLER MURRAY
2016-PRESENT REV. JOHN R. ODAMS
